Possible BMW Performance Intake filter replacement by AFE

[Secono330ci]

I posted this on e46fanatics and wanted to share this here also:

During one of my deep late night searches on the web, I think I may have found a "high performance" drop in filter that would work with the BMW Performance intake.

The current Napa/Mann/Fram replacement filters that people are using are originally manufactured for the 1994-1998 Pontiac Grand-Am. I did a bit of digging and found that the 2004 Pontiac Grand-Am filter (larger displacement engine) is a different part number, but has the EXACT SAME DIMENSIONS as the 1994 one. So I looked under the 2004 model and viola! AFE makes a replacement.

AFE Part number: 30-10081 (Pro 5 R) 31-10081 (Pro Dry S)
http://afepower.com/shop/details_new.php?partno=30-10081&filter&menu=gas&engine=3.4L&searchtype=vehicle&make=Pontiac&model=Grand%20Am&year=2004&engine=3.4L&&brandID=59

Comes in either an oiled "Pro 5 R" or a non-oiled "Pro Dry S".

Conclusion:
No oil (if you go with the dry one), pleats seem to be in the right direction, rubber looks flimsy enough to bend around the bracket, and it's still cheaper than the BMW filter.
Not to mention you're getting a lot more flow than the paper filters and it'll sound much better.

Now someone needs to be the guinea pig :)

[PirateZHP]

Someone donate a BMW Perf Intake to me and I will be the guinea pig...

[Avetiso]

Someone donate a BMW Perf Intake to me and I will be the guinea pig...

:ROFL

Sent from my SM-N900T using Tapatalk

[SoCalZman]

So they are a "synthetic" material with 50% better flow than the paper filter if I am reading this correctly. That would also mean they do less actual filtering right? I guess it's a trade off. Would love to see dyno sheets comparing paper to this

[ELCID86]

I posted this on e46fanatics and wanted to share this here also:

During one of my deep late night searches on the web, I think I may have found a "high performance" drop in filter that would work with the BMW Performance intake.

The current Napa/Mann/Fram replacement filters that people are using are originally manufactured for the 1994-1998 Pontiac Grand-Am. I did a bit of digging and found that the 2004 Pontiac Grand-Am filter (larger displacement engine) is a different part number, but has the EXACT SAME DIMENSIONS as the 1994 one. So I looked under the 2004 model and viola! AFE makes a replacement.

AFE Part number: 30-10081 (Pro 5 R) 31-10081 (Pro Dry S)
http://afepower.com/shop/details_new...4L&&brandID=59

Comes in either an oiled "Pro 5 R" or a non-oiled "Pro Dry S".

Conclusion:
No oil (if you go with the dry one), pleats seem to be in the right direction, rubber looks flimsy enough to bend around the bracket, and it's still cheaper than the BMW filter.
Not to mention you're getting a lot more flow than the paper filters and it'll sound much better.

Now someone needs to be the guinea pig :)

Good research. We should update the CAI thread.

Link doesn't work for me.

[wsmeyer]

If URL's are too long they get screwed up somewhere.

Short URL: http://tinyurl.com/lbxvufw

No one wants a $60 paperweight but maybe we can get 6 people chip in $10 ?? PayPal all the money to one of the admins who then chooses who gets to be the tester?

[Secono330ci]

So they are a "synthetic" material with 50% better flow than the paper filter if I am reading this correctly. That would also mean they do less actual filtering right? I guess it's a trade off. Would love to see dyno sheets comparing paper to this

Well I would say the paper is over-restrictive. It's cheap to produce, so that's why BMW uses it. Keep in mind that on the CSL, BMW used a higher flow filter similar to these.

For this intake, the non-oiled would be the better choice since it won't contaminate the MAF. It still has a filtration percentage of 99.2%. AFE filters are among the best IMO. My first choice would be AEM since they specialize in Dry-Flow technology, and produce one hell of a filter, but they do not make the size.

I'm not saying the BMW filter isn't good, but this will clearly out flow it and sound better.

[johnrando]

All that's likely true if it fits.

[Hornung418]

That looks like my drop in filter...doesn't look like it will bend the same as the perf intake.

Sent from my GS3.

[JKO_ZHP]

At the price, I will stick with my $8 filters. That one would get me 7 shipped to my door.
Plus, re-washable filters have never sat well with me. No matter how you clean it, it's very unlikely that one would be able to remove 100% of the impurities, which would mean as time goes on, performance goes down as air restriction goes up, however slow it may be.

Also, those pleats look similar to those of K&N's. In which case, there is wire mesh in between the fabric so it would not be able to curve to fit into the intake.

[Secono330ci]

This is just another possible option I wanted to throw out there. I used to own a BMW performance intake and hated the paper filter part of it. I will most likely get one again soon though and modify it a bit to my liking (not just the filter). If the AFE doesn't fit then I'll have AEM build me a custom filter. Hopefully someone can test this out or contact AFE and see how flexible it is.

As for cleaning it, they clean up well. The flow rate is at least double that of a standard paper filter.

[JKO_ZHP]

I will email or call them later after - if they are flexible and can be bent to fit the intake then I will get one.
Would like to see/hear/feel how it stacks up against a regular filter.

[Secono330ci]

Nice! Let's hope it works and let us know what they say.

[johnrando]

Thx JKO.

[Secono330ci]

I'm going to order this next week. I'm hoping it works! If not I'm going to work with afe and see if they can make us direct replacements for ours.

[WOLFN8TR]

I'm going to order this next week. I'm hoping it works! If not I'm going to work with afe and see if they can make us direct replacements for ours.

That would be sweet...

[rkneeshaw]

Anyone actually try this yet in a BMW Performance Filter?

[Secono330ci]

I tried a k&n that was almost identical in size and it barely fit. A couple potholes and it would have came off.

Check out my new thread guys. I would love to get this going.

http://www.zhpmafia.com/forums/showthread.php?13897-BMW-Performance-Intake-Filter.-Possible-alternative-from-AFE-AEM